forum The Roodeness Shenanigans

Started May 27, 2020 by Deleted user

tune

Edit topic

I mean my class read Between Shades of Grey, Salt to the Sea, Hunting Spirit Bear, and Jekyll and Hyde for middle school. Same with Frankenstein, Hamlet, and The House of the Scorpion.

Red Midnight too!! jfc that was brutal and we read it in 5th grade. Prisoner B-3087 too.

uhhhhhhhhhhhh

I read The Red Badge of Courage and Fever 17something in my middle school

That's it, that i can remember

What traumatized you in that?

No exactly, that's my point. It's not traumatizing at all, and it's the only thing I can think of that could, in any way, have been traumatizing

To be fair their was that one time with the catapults loaded with

Between Shades of Grey,

?

What traumatized you in that?

No exactly, that's my point. It's not traumatizing at all, and it's the only thing I can think of that could, in any way, have been traumatizing

To be fair their was that one time with the catapults loaded with

Spoiler - click to show.

the branded heads of fallen soldiers.

Oh yeah, I forgot about that

Ngl, the most traumatizing part (to me) is the fucking barrow wights lmao

I can't believe we read Red Midnight in 5th grade. Iread it in 7th because I made the mistake of choosing The Voyage of the Frog and nearly being bored to death, but still.

What traumatized you in that?

No exactly, that's my point. It's not traumatizing at all, and it's the only thing I can think of that could, in any way, have been traumatizing

To be fair their was that one time with the catapults loaded with

Spoiler - click to show.

the branded heads of fallen soldiers.

Oh yeah, I forgot about that

Ngl, the most traumatizing part (to me) is the fucking barrow wights lmao

Completely fair they were creepy.

Between Shades of Grey,

?

It might be Gray tbh, I don't remember. It's about a teenage Lithuanian girl who's sent to a Soviet labor camp with her family in the 1940s. Pretty intense stuff in it, as you can probably guess.

i mean just recently my ela class read a book that featured a lot of heavy abuse perpetuated by the main male character, and then he committed suicide. i don't remember anything standing out in what i read as a kid, but considering i was reading at a college level in like third grade(the librarians wouldn't let you check certain age level books out based on your grade, and my teachers would have to be like 'just let the kid get the book, have you seen their reading score?') i'm sure i read plenty of things that i definitely shouldn't have.

What traumatized you in that?

No exactly, that's my point. It's not traumatizing at all, and it's the only thing I can think of that could, in any way, have been traumatizing

To be fair their was that one time with the catapults loaded with

Spoiler - click to show.

the branded heads of fallen soldiers.

Oh yeah, I forgot about that

Ngl, the most traumatizing part (to me) is the fucking barrow wights lmao

Completely fair they were creepy.

Well yeah, but like. Nothing else fazed me except those guys, and it's just hilarious to me that eight or nine year old me read all the battle scenes, Shelob, the ghost king, the Nazgul, all of that, and decided that the barrow wights were the scariest of all of it

my dumb ass started anne frank's diary and stopped reading because i thought it was boring

I mean my class read Between Shades of Grey, Salt to the Sea, Hunting Spirit Bear, and Jekyll and Hyde for middle school. Same with Frankenstein, Hamlet, and The House of the Scorpion.

salt to the sea was brutal

I went to a Catholic school and a lot of the books we read were probably above our age level tbh. Like I said, we were reading gothic lit in 7th grade. And I've always had a super high reading level so the teachers were pretty chill with me reading whatever, I remember one time my friend's mom told me I should wait to read the 6th and 7th HP books because they got "dark" and I was just like "??? and???" lol

my dumb ass started anne frank's diary and stopped reading because i thought it was boring

We only read the play version, I want to read the real one at some point

I mean my class read Between Shades of Grey, Salt to the Sea, Hunting Spirit Bear, and Jekyll and Hyde for middle school. Same with Frankenstein, Hamlet, and The House of the Scorpion.

salt to the sea was brutal

I need to reread it, I know I almost cried at the ending.

the real one is really interesting. really, really shockingly sad ofc, but it's good

oh yeah, i had a john green kick in fifth grade or so. not saying any of that is horribly traumatizing but some of it is definitely not fifth grade appropriate

I read somewhere that Anne Frank was potentially queer?? Can anyone who's actually read it confirm that??

yeah, there's some stuff about her wanting to kiss a girl that could signal that she was gay or bisexual. at the same time, as a queer jewish person, it's really not respectful to speculate about that stuff relating to a child considering the nature of her story.

Ooh okay. I just wanted to ask? But yeah I definitely get that it's not respectful, my bad

Did anyone else read Petey for school? That one made me sad for a bit

Ooh okay. I just wanted to ask? But yeah I definitely get that it's not respectful, my bad

oh seriously man don't worry about it! you didn't do anything wrong– but there are some people who take it too far; call her a 'bisexual icon' and all that.

My biology teacher (a great hyooman) recommended To Destroy You is No Loss about a year ago, but he warned that it fucked him up bad for weeks so if I was gunna read it I better be emotionally stable.
Haven't summed up the courage for that one yet. Has anyone read it?

I wanna read They Both Die at the End. Just to see if I’m sad. Probs will be.

Ooh okay. I just wanted to ask? But yeah I definitely get that it's not respectful, my bad

oh seriously man don't worry about it! you didn't do anything wrong– but there are some people who take it too far; call her a 'bisexual icon' and all that.

That sort of thing is super weird in general, like it's good to know about historical LGBTQ people and all but I don't like it when people are like "omg the original Bicon" and stuff, especially when we don't even know if that's how they'd identify. And it's especially weird to say that about a teenage girl who died in the Holocaust, like that should not be your takeaway from reading her diary.

I wanna read They Both Die at the End. Just to see if I’m sad. Probs will be.

I cried for way too long. Read it.

I wanna read They Both Die at the End. Just to see if I’m sad. Probs will be.

Same. I haven't read anything by Silvera but I know that Lizzie and I think also Ice (correct me if I'm wrong) really liked it

Plus it's free if you have Hoopla so

I wanna read They Both Die at the End. Just to see if I’m sad. Probs will be.

Same. I haven't read anything by Silvera but I know that Lizzie and I think also Ice (correct me if I'm wrong) really liked it

Oh yeah I loved it. Cried super hard at the end, but I loved it