forum The Pravaci Court - Leave me a critique!
Started by @LittleBear group
tune

people_alt 69 followers

@TryToDoItWrite

Hey!! Looks like you're getting some good writing done for NaNo (unlike this girl)!
Let's jump right in!
Maybe it's because my brain is addled from the German learning and the sickness I'm plagued with rn, but this definitely feels confused. It also could be that it's not in chronological order from what I've seen last.

Details:

It hurt him to know that he was the source and there was nothing he could do to fix it. ((or There was shame clearly etched into his features and the telltale glisten in his eyes.(I feel like this might be a show vs tell situation here))

Yeah, it's a show/tell thing. I think out of everything here, the sentence. "There was shame clearly etched into his features" kinda both shows and tells the audience everything we need to know–what he's feeling and how his face looks. (I would cut the word "there" by rewriting into "Shame etched hard lines into his features." or something like that)

The cloud of sleep dissolved. “Oh.” All the tension left her and she drew in on herself.

I see what you're going for here, but "cloud of sleep" as a descriptor doesn't really give a feeling of tension. So, she wakes up fully, realizes it's Kraio (her brother, right? just making sure i'm keeping the characters all straight), and then kinda slumps down, all fighting instincts gone. You probably don't have to say anything more than
“It’s me.”
"Oh…" All the tension left her, and she slumped down again.
or something like that.

“He was your first.”

“Yes, and it was an accident.”

“Mine was last night too. For all our training, I didn’t realize how fragile we can be.”

“I thought that it would be deliberate. That the situation would be life or death.”

“It was, the lives of hundreds of thousands.”

“We had to do it.”

“Yes. Baston’s wife was there. She’s the one who told us to do it.”

I think this is one of the places I got confused. It's what author bloggers like to call "talking head syndrome" (i'm sure you're like me and read those blogs looking for input lol) I'm getting confused with who's saying what because the tone of the two are pretty much the same.

“No,” Nati whispered and we sat for a time, sinking ever deeper into the evil. “Poor Baston”.

This is dark, but I like this detail, bc it brings the darkness fully to the audience's attention in a horrible horrible example. But, I would clarify the metaphor a bit more– "sinking ever deeper into our own dark thoughts" or something like that

“He would have let you leave.”

i don't understand this line, but maybe it's just because it's out of order and skipping ahead

“Will you stay with me? Just for tonight?” She asked and suddenly we were small again.

Again, love this metaphor, but i feel like it, in this instance, it needs bit more detail/clarification.
"and suddenly we were small children again."
cause the word small could mean, meak, scared, or actually small as in young or in stature.

All in all, I totally got the emotions of Nati and that's the point of this kind of "aftermath of a hard battle won" type scene! Good job!!! I hope NaNo has been going better for you than me! lol I should probably check the website :)

@LittleBear group

Omg! I'm so sorry you're feeling under the weather! But Happy Thanksgiving from the States!! And yes, I'm thinking that this might be my first chapter so it's totally not in chronological order. As always, thank you so much for your awesome edits/inputs. I think I'll up load it again with new edits and with everything done (no story jumps). And I've barely made a dent in that 50,000 words, ugh its SO BIG!

@TryToDoItWrite

And I've barely made a dent in that 50,000 words, ugh its SO BIG!

Yes, sAme! mine started off so strong and then…….life…..

I think I'll up load it again with new edits and with everything done

oh yeah, send me whatever, any time! It may take a week (whoops) but i'll always get back to ya :)

@LittleBear group

Hey, sorry I haven't been able to write anything, things have been SUPER busy! But I just wanted to let you know that the army just told me where I'm going to be living! I'm going to Korea!!!

@TryToDoItWrite

Oh my gosh!!! That's so cool!! Are you nervous? Are you gonna try and learn the language?
I've been insanely busy too, I totally get it
I've been going through a period in my writing that I really think I just need to write a short story in order to finish something (to prove to myself that I can actually finish something)

@LittleBear group

Haha! So I'm actually half Korean, I've never been and my mom hasn't been back in 27+ years so I'm more excited to meet her side of the family than anything else. My Korean is awful though (I speak like a drunk two-year-old sailor, lots of cursing, no conjugation, basic grammar, and I can barely read and write), so I downloaded duolingo and I'm trying to get the basics down!
AND omfg do I get that feeling! Just know that i'm going to be over here cheering you on and waiting patiently to read it! :)

@LittleBear group

As per usual, the more that I need to get to work, the more my characters are coming to the surface… Here is some cutesy stuff:

[Nati and Stris. Mama (O'Nell) is from a different country so her mannerisms are a little different. Sela is Nati and Kraio's etiquette teacher]

“Gods, I do not know why, but these chambers always make me nervous,” he said through gritted teeth.

Without thinking, I grabbed his hands and brought his knuckles to my lips and kissed them gently, just as Mama had done so many times before.

“What are you doing?” He whispered.

“I, I –” I stammered, “my mother – is this not normal?” I dropped his hands, suddenly feeling self-conscious.

“No, not in Darion,” Stris chuckled and I felt like shrinking in on myself. All of those lessons with Sela, and I had still managed to paint myself as an outsider.

“But perhaps it should be.” And he took my hands in his and kissed my knuckles. But there was something entirely different about the gesture.
Mama’s gesture was a comfort; the way she put it, it ‘pulled away anxiety to leave only calm’.

His was not calming. His eyes held me captive and even if I wished, I could not have broken free. The warmth of his lips swept over my knuckles and sparked something in me.

“Yes,” I whispered, “Perhaps.”

Someone turned the doorknob and instantaneously, we lept apart.
____________________

[Nati and Stris]

“Hi!” she giggled, “I knew you’d come! You’re always there.” She mumbled something that sounded like “rotten bastard.” But still in the cheeriest of tones.

“What have you been drinking?” I asked, picking up one of the empty glasses on the side table. It smelled vaguely of sugar and berries.

“Aelina kept bringing them to me,” she threw her hands up. “She said they were” she hickuped and covered her mouth in surprise. “Special.”

Aelina. That girl was going get herself into trouble. “Come here. Can you stand?” “Where in the palace are you staying?”

“I don’t remember?” She said as she tried to get up, tried being the operative word. She would have crumpled to the floor if I hadn’t caught her.

“Alright, you’re coming with me. Time for bed.” I said as I swept her up into my arms.

“My! How forward of you!” She said, throwing one hand around my shoulders and the other to her hair.

I could feel the heat of my embarrassment burning my cheeks. “I’ll take the lounge.”

Carries her to the Seblire section of the palace. Where the Bestolin wing used to be.

… I set her on the bed. And she looked at me for a long moment. “You know that you’re beautiful?”

“Nati, we’ve had this discussion. I look like your brother.”

She waved a hand “Yes, but you’re different. You’re… I don’t know. You make me feel things. Not supposed to…” her voice became deep and she waved her hands about. “Might compromise the mission.” Her voice returned to her lovely register as she said “Pha! I still think you have a cute butt. And your poetry makes me blush and I think you’re grand.”

“Nati, you’re drunk.” I could not help but chuckle. “It’s time to go to sleep now.”

“Nati, do this. Nati, do that.” She sighed, kicking off her boots.
_______________________

[Siblingness. Kraio and Nati]

“Kraio had I not grown up with you, I would be convinced that you are actually a child.”

He looked up at me, his cheeks almost bursting with sweets, and mumbled something that vaguely resembled, “Fight me.”

“A few more of those and you will be much to fat for any of that,” I said.
____________________

[Solin and Eline (Stris and Kraio's Parents) out for a walk on the palace grounds]

“Kiss me.” I stopped in my tracks.

"Pardon?”

“Kiss me, like you need me more than air. Like I am the first breath of sea air you have ever had. Like the blessed rain after a drought.”

He grabbed my hand and spun me towards him. Even with our gloves in the way, I could feel the heat passing between them. With his spare hand, he swept a strand of hair from my face, his fingers lingered on my cheek. “Is something the matter?”

“Yes. no.” I shook my head. “I’m just feeling particularly insignificant at the moment.” That and I wanted to feel as if he needed me in the way I needed him.

He let my hand go to pull me closer to him. His eyes lingered on my mouth a moment before he ran his thumb over my lower lip. “Here? We’re not alone.”

“I don’t care,” I whispered.

He lowered his lips to mine, soft and tender, he breathed life into me. Warmth raced across my lips, yet I needed more. He opened unto me and I to him. I drank him in. I did not care who saw. The taste of him on my tongue was enough to chase all thoughts of propriety away.

He pulled a whisper away. “You are more precious to me than anything I have ever experienced. You are incomparable.” He murmured against my lips.

“You keep talking like that and I’ll have you right here.”

“Can’t have that,” he laughed and kissed me on the forehead. “Also, you need to leave the poetry to me, that was particularly awful”

“Oh, come on!”

“Mustn’t let that head of yours get much bigger”

“Oh!” I scoffed. “That’s it. No more for you.” And I danced away from him. I could see what he was doing, and it was working remarkably well.
____________________

[Erion while he is training to be an assassin]

Sela whispers in my ear but all I hear is Marielle. She is so clear to me, the hearty peal of her laughter, the feeling of her arm being so close to mine that I could almost feel the warmth of her. I remembered looking up at the stars from the palace celling when the Pravaci Court was in session [and all of the Pravaci Children were living in the wings]. It was all of us. Sol and Jer. Mari and Eline. We would laugh late into the night and without fail, Mari and I were always the last to fall asleep. Sometimes we were already next to each other. Other times we would whisper over the others. And sometimes when I was feeling particularly bold, I would get up and slip in next to her and we would look at each other instead of the stars.

Those nights I wanted nothing more than to reach out and touch her cheek. But I held back. For some reason, that had felt too bold. I didn’t want to make her feel… I couldn’t put it to words then, now I can. I did not want to make her feel like her place among us was dependent on how we felt about her. How I felt about her. She tried to hide it, but sometimes I would see her catching herself – finding the delicate balance between demure ladies maid befitting court and the firebrand that we loved.

It hits me like a wave.

I miss her.

I miss her more than I miss my brothers. More than I miss Mother.

“Erion,” Sela’s finger trailed down my cheek. “You are far away again. Come back.”

@TryToDoItWrite

HOLY–!!
…these little snippets made me feel so single lolllll

Okay honestly not much to say bc theyre all so good!

Thoughts:

Without thinking, I grabbed his hands and brought his knuckles to my lips and kissed them gently, just as Mama had done so many times before.
“What are you doing?” He whispered.
“I, I –” I stammered, “my mother – is this not normal?” I dropped his hands, suddenly feeling self-conscious.
“No, not in Darion,” Stris chuckled and I felt like shrinking in on myself. All of those lessons with Sela, and I had still managed to paint myself as an outsider.

soo I got exactly what you were going for–the gesture of affection that is not usual in Darion that her mother used to use as a comfort
But throw in that more ppl than just her mother does this where she is from (also i would change up order of actions..flustered person would immediately drop the hand)

"“What are you doing?” He whispered.
I dropped his hands, suddenly feeling self-conscious. "Oh–I–" I stammered. " In (name of place) we would – is this not normal? Nevermind." I felt like shrinking in on myself.
"No, not in Darion," Stris chuckled. All of those lessons with Sela, and I had still managed to paint myself as an outsider.

It smelled vaguely of sugar and berries.

Don't forget that alcohol smells like alcohol even when mixed with sugar and berries
You could mention it being smelt on her breath too

tried being the operative word.

? I'm confused lol

You make me feel things. Not supposed to…” her voice became deep and she waved her hands about. “Might compromise the mission.” Her voice returned to her lovely register

What kind of deep? and why deep here with this sentence? in emotion? with the alcohol? I don't get the effect I think you were going for

Kiss me.” I stopped in my tracks.
"Pardon?”

Okay this whole scene made me melt from cuteness

I had particular trouble with this one with following who said what during the dialog. Throw in a couple more dialog tags and I think you're golden for this one

“Erion,” Sela’s finger trailed down my cheek. “You are far away again. Come back.”

Oooooof I'm feeling things
I love this scene!

Wonderful Valentines Day post lol :))

@LittleBear group

As always, thanks again for the edits:)! Your actions always manage to make me smile!

So I have a big ask. I am going on spring break soon and I am going to a small cabin with NO WIFI insert screaming emoji and planning to do all of the homework ever and write a ton with no distractions. So, I'm bound to run into some writer's block. Do you have anything that you would like to see me write, any character scenarios, ships? Idk. Anything you'd like me to edit?

@TryToDoItWrite

holy crap hi! @WriteOutofTime

@LittleBear good! I've been doing things like gardening and caring for the six kittens I found hiding in my dad's car engine!

how are both of yall?

my brother has been trying to convince me to write my current WIP as a screenplay. he's an aspiring film maker and has now promised to do a scene from it as a short film (don't know if he'll ever get around to it lol)

@LittleBear group

@TryToDoItWrite, OMG CUTE! My boyfriend's boxer just had puppies and so when he facetimes me he always shows me them! If you're comfortable with it, Could you show us a picture of the kittens? ONLY if you're comfortable with it! AND OMG YES, screenplay! Screenplay! Bangs fits against the table Screenplay! I would watch the hell out of it!

@WriteOutofTime Same dude same, in fact, I just rewatched Interstellar again. Holy crap what a movie.

So, If you guys haven't seen it (omg go watch it. If you haven't in a while, go watch it again) there is a scene where the daughter feels utterly betrayed by her dad and she literally says "Did you know? Did you leave us here to die?" And as we all know… I am a terrible person and am horrible to my characters. So I've been hit with the almighty bolt of inspiration out of my writer's block. I'm probably going to be writing through the night. Scene coming to yall soon.

Until then, what do y'all think of the title "Sultan of Secrets" for one of the characters? Cheesy or slightly ominous?

Also, I'm graduating college in like 4 weeks… just took the last finals of my life. I'm a real adult. I don't like it.

@WriteOutofTime

interstellar's soundtrack and visuals were amazing!! im excited for the scene youre writing!

sultan of secrets could go either way depending on the context. i think you should stick with it unless you think of something definitely better and time will tell if it fits.

i'm halfway through college now and im shook by that, so i cant imagine just…being done. wow. best of luck to you! what are your adult plans?

@LittleBear group

Truuuue.

Yeah, I can't really imagine it either… So for adult plans? Well, I think I already told @TryToDoItWrite, but I go West Point the Army College. So my soul has been sold to the government and I will be an officer in like a week! The President wants to give the commencement speech at my graduation, so I have to fly back to New York in a little bit. I'm a little nervous…

But after that, I have a little bit of training in Missouri, then I will be living in South Korea for my first assignment! I'll be doing work on looking at chemical weapons and WMDs for a few years before going to Intelligence!

@TryToDoItWrite

@LittleBear wow… you're literally a real adulty adult….that all sounds so awesome though!! you'll have so much fuel for writing but not a lot of time!

I took a gap year for exchange so I'm just now starting college in August (moving out of my house into an apartment alone is not as scary as going to Germany all alone lol) Guess that makes me the baby here……

Yeah, I agree about the title and I'll have to see it in context!

hehehe i'd love to show you pictures of the kittens

@WriteOutofTime mind if I ask what you're majoring in?

@TryToDoItWrite

That's awesome!! We have similar interests i see..I'm not premed but I'm planning on going into neuroscience research!
(I'm neurosci major with focus in molecular and cellular with german minor)

@TryToDoItWrite

ehehe guys do yall wanna read something from four years ago of mine when i first started writing? its so bad i want to cryyyyy lol

but lowkey my style hasn't changed…just its so cliche like YIKES and i didn't know how to format and what was my POV??? idek

The day would have been a beautiful one, Naomi Avenir thought. The sun had just risen and the morning dew was still fresh on the grass at the edges of the dirt road. The tree’s soft new leaves fluttered in the spring breeze.
But the birds weren’t singing. A foreign voice shouted at an old woman who was slow in clearing the road. A baby wailed.
It would’ve been a nice day if her enemies hadn’t just rode into her helpless village to claim victory. Naomi and her people knelt as the procession of Kinesis warriors kicked up dust in the roads. They were spreading out, like a disease, throughout the whole town.
“Eyes down, vermin,” one yelled.
A pathetic yelp came from her left. Naomi saw soldiers forcing down the heads of everyone kneeling beside the road. Those who weren’t forced did so out of fear; and Naomi was. Closing her eyes, she took a deep breath. A line of ants marched across the dirt below, oblivious to the human army traveling in a similar fashion. On the dirt, what had once been a tiny white flower lay. The pounding of feet mixed with jeering shouts and muffled cries of pain made her fists curl at her side.
She flicked her bangs aside and lifted her eyes. A party all mounted on horses approached, a flurry of red and black. They were out of place compared to the soft browns and muted blues of her tribe. She hardened her gaze and stood to her full height. A murmur rose around her. As the horses reached the point where she stood, the riders paused. Her heart rate refused to slow as willed herself not to waver.
“Kneel Manipulator scum,” a soldier walking next to the riders shouted.
She did not move.
“Alexander.” The man seated on the finest horse, in the most luxurious robes, with his nose in the air motioned vaguely toward the defiant villager. Naomi didn’t have time to get a good look at the younger man all in black before a violent force jerked her forward. The crowd around let out a sudden cry of fear. It was like gravity had shifted for her, and her alone. She tumbled toward the group of horses, stopping just short of barreling straight into the house right in front of her.
She looked up and met the eyes of her tormentor. She had impression of jade green eyes and freckles before the older man spoke to her.
“Name?”
Naomi turned to him, but he wasn’t even looking at her. He spoke to the air above her head. Naomi knew he was Dominic Felch, the ruler of Kinesis Nation.
“What?” She said stupidly.
“Alexander.”
Her mind was sluggish. That’s definitely not my name, old man, she thought for a second. Then panic shot through her like ice.. She tried to step backward, but Alexander’s hand rose quickly. As he clenched his fist, a heavy force pressed down on her chest. It was as if a house had fallen on top of her lungs. Stars shot through her vision, and the dirt road swam under her. Then it stopped as suddenly as it had started. She gasped in a huge lung-full of the spring air. Her legs felt like liquid but she refused to kneel.
“I asked you what your name was.”
“Naomi,” she coughed out.
“Talent?”
“None.” Lying is easier when you are still struggling for breath, she reasoned grimly.
“Get rid of her then, Alexander. Teach a lesson to the others.”
It was only then did a flicker of doubt enter Alexander’s mind. Naomi looked wildly at him, and heard, If she has no Talent then she can’t be the one. The one? They came here looking for one person. They had invaded her helpless, peaceful tribe on account of one person. Her face blanched in fury as she watched the two men decide her fate.
“Grandfather,” he said softly, “no point in killing her.”
The white-haired man sighed exasperatedly at his grandson.
“I didn’t mean kill her, Xander. Just get her out of my sight.”
Alexander raised his arm again, but slowly, almost gently. Naomi floated weightlessly above the ground, writhing and struggling. “Put me down, you bastard! ” she yelled.
“Fine.”
As if he was slashing a knife, he swung his arm down. Naomi came crashing to the ground. Pain exploded in her head and arm. She heard a loud scream that she recognized dimly to be her own. The last thing she remembered seeing was the white wildflower crushed in the road, directly under her nose.

“Gnomy. Gnomy!” Matthew Avenir shook his sister, trying to rouse her. Only when she groaned then coughed into the dirt did he stop his constant shaking of her shoulders. Naomi blinked and tried to focus on her surroundings. She was still in the road, but everyone was clearing out. She saw Sean Allen, the innkeeper, give her a sympathetic glance before shuffling off in the direction of the inn.
“What’s going on? What happened?”
“Everyone was told to go home. They took Dad and Grandma somewhere. Mom’s at the house.”
Naomi nodded and pulled herself to her feet. Her four year-old brother must be scared out of his mind, but he was putting on a brave face.
“Gnomy you’ve got blood on your face.” She checked, and blood was in fact pouring out of her nose.
“Just a nose bleed Matty. Let’s go.” She swept her brother up. He was light, even for a four year-old, but her muscles still screamed in protest.
Some sixth sense had warned her of the approaching enemy before Alexander’s voice said, “You’ve been ordered to go home.”
Naomi whipped around, clutching her brother tightly.
“We’re going,” she said scathyingly, “Took a moment to peel myself off the road.”
“Allow me to escort you.” As he took a step towards her, she stepped back and instinctively shielded Matthew with her body. She glared at him furiously, biting back retorts that would make her grandfather roll in his grave. He used to tell Naomi that she had the temper of a Fire Talent.
“Thank you, but I’m disinclined to accept.” Naomi finally hissed between clenched teeth. She tried turning away, but a hand on her shoulder stopped her.
“I wasn’t asking.”
Naomi jerked away, and started the familiar walk home. The streets were unnaturally empty; doors were shut tightly; windows were shuttered closed that would normally be flung wide open to catch the early spring winds. She ignored the Kinesis warrior following close behind.
“Go tell Mom that I’m fine.” She ushered Matthew through the door then turned back to Alexander Felch.
“What do you want?” She growled at him.
He blinked in surprise and actually took a small step backwards from the furious girl. She looked him dead in the eye, straining her Talent to hear his thoughts.
“What's the point of all this? Who are you looking for?”
Naomi’s heart stuttered in his rapid beating. She had said too much. She had only heard him think that they were looking for someone.
“What did you say?”
Maybe she could talk her way out of this.
“You said that earlier. That I'm not the one? Who are you looking for?”
“No,” He shook his head slowly, frowning as he tried to recall what had happened, “I thought that.”
“No,” she said firmly, “ You definitely said it. Otherwise how could I have known?”
He seemed to see her for the first time. He swept his gaze over her, taking in her long tunic in the color of the Ike Tribe, olive skin, dark hair that matched her dark eyes; eyes that shot daggers at him. She radiated a sense of righteous fury and false confidence. She stood, hands on hips, in the middle of the doorway.
“Naomi right?”
“What?”
“Your name; it's Naomi.”
“Yes, but-”
“Last name?”
“Are you not-?”
“You asked me what I wanted. I want your last name.”
“It's Avenir.”
He nodded like this was vital information.
“Naomi Avenir,” he stepped closer, using his height advantage to tower over her, “just keep your nose out of things that shouldn't concern you.”
“That's rich coming from you.”
He narrowed his eyes. “Watch yourself.”
“I would if I could afford a mirror.”